The action for a declaration of non-infringement (DNI) is the mirror image of the infringement action: it is not the proprietor who attacks, but the operator — actual or potential — who takes the initiative to have it established that it does not infringe (A32(1)(b) UPCA and R61 to R74 RoP UPC).

Overview

The idea is simple: rather than waiting, with the sword of Damocles hanging over its head, for the proprietor to deign (or not) to bring an infringement action, the operator itself brings the matter before the Court to have it declared that its product or process does not fall within the patent. It is a tool of legal certainty, invaluable before an industrial or commercial launch.

Conditions of the action

Who may bring the action, and against whom

A person who performs, or proposes to perform, a specific act may bring the action against the patent proprietor or the licensee entitled to bring infringement proceedings (R61.1 and R61.2 RoP UPC).

Standing

One does not go to court in a vacuum: the action is available only if (R61.1 RoP UPC):

  • the proprietor (or licensee) has asserted that the act constitutes an infringement; or
  • failing that, the claimant has requested the proprietor in writing, giving full particulars of the act in question, to acknowledge that there is no infringement, and the proprietor has refused or failed to respond within one month.

In other words, a minimum of threat is required: an accusation, or at the very least an awkward silence in the face of a request for acknowledgement.

The competent division

Unlike the infringement action, which is brought before a local or regional division, the action for a declaration of non-infringement falls within the competence of the central division, unless an infringement action is already pending between the same parties before a local or regional division, or the parties agree on another division (A33(4) and (7) UPCA and R63 RoP UPC).

The Statement for a declaration of non-infringement

The Statement contains the particulars identifying the action as for an infringement action, evidence that the conditions of Rule 61 are met, the declaration sought, the reasons why the act does not constitute an infringement (including the proposed construction of the claims), the facts and evidence, an estimate of the value if it exceeds €500,000, and the list of documents (R63 RoP UPC).

Fee

The action is subject to the fixed fee of €14,600 and, if its value exceeds €500,000, to the value-based fee, the value being determined by the judge-rapporteur during the interim procedure (R70 and R74 RoP UPC; see “Court fees and value of the action”).

The action may be combined with a revocation action against the same patent; both fees are then payable (R77 RoP UPC). A classic combination: “your patent is invalid, and in any case I do not infringe it”.

Course of the proceedings

The written procedure consists of a Statement initiating the action, a Statement of defence (within two months), then, optionally, a reply and a rejoinder (each within one month) (R62, R67 and R69 RoP UPC). The defendant may lodge a preliminary objection (R66 RoP UPC), and its defence contains the same particulars as in infringement matters (R68 RoP UPC).

For the rest (examination as to formal requirements, judge-rapporteur, technically qualified judge, closure), the rules of the infringement action apply (R65, R71 to R73 RoP UPC): the details are set out on the page “Infringement action”.

Interplay with the infringement action

This is the sensitive point. If, while an action for a declaration of non-infringement is pending before the central division, the proprietor or its exclusive licensee brings an infringement action against the same claimant, concerning the same patent, before a local or regional division within three months of the date on which the non-infringement action was initiated, the central division stays the latter (A33(6) UPCA and R76.3 RoP UPC).

Put simply: the DNI allows one to take the initiative… but the proprietor retains, for three months, the option of taking back control by choosing its own battleground. After that, there is no automatic stay: the presiding judges of the panels concerned consult each other (R76.3 RoP UPC).

See also